Responding to Low Personal Injury Settlements

Responding to Low Personal Injury Settlements
Calendar icon April 12, 2021

If you have a personal injury case, and your damages and injuries are known (they got into your medical record) your (or you and your attorney if you hired one) will send a demand letter to the liable person or their insurance company. The insurers may respond to your demand letter with a low settlement (also known as “low-ball”). How you will respond to this will affect the money you will get and your ability to cover your medical bills, lost wages and other damages and expenses related to your injury.

It’s best if you have a New York personal injury attorney to guide you through this and negotiate the offer.

Analyze the Offer

It’s easy to get upset after a low-ball offer especially if your injury was serious and you have big bile of medical bills.

But, stay calm and analyze the offer. You don’t have to send an emotional response to the insurance company. Also, don’t make the mistake to accept this first low-ball offer.

Many people panic and believe that there is no chance for a higher offer, so they accept the small settlement even though they can get a higher offer with a proper negotiation.

The first offer by the insurance company is just the beginning of the settlement negotiations.

Respond in Writing

Before you write a formal response, you can send the adjuster an email or call them, asking detailed questions that will evaluate the basics for the low first offer. The answers to the questions will give you a clearer picture and guidance for the formal draft of your response.

The first low offer may occur because you didn’t send sufficient info about your injuries and other losses. If this is the case, give the adjuster important info such as your medical bills, lost wages and other relevant information.

If you don’t do this in your first demand letter, focus on the subjective and emotional points of your case. The timeline of the accident and your medical treatment were probably described in your first demand letter, so make sure you don’t repeat yourself. If you wrote the costs and date of your surgery in the first demand letter, don’t repeat that. Instead, write about the effects of the injury (additional medications, the hospital stay).

Now it’s a good time to write about the non-economic damages i.e your pain and suffering. You have gone through stress, trauma and other emotional states that the injury put you through. State that you no longer are able to enjoy the hobbies you used to have, for example.

Form Your Counteroffer

It’s not a very good idea to respond to a low-ball offer for your injury with a super high counteroffer. Keep a professional and detailed approach to your injury settlement negotiations, but consider the amount you believe you deserve and the limits of the applicable insurance coverage. Also, consider that the at-fault party has potential assets.

Maybe your injury was severe and changed the quality of your life forever and you may believe that you deserve $50 000. But, the other side may have low insurance policy limits, and your best chance is to get $25 000. Your reasonable counteroffer can vary between $35 000 – $40 000

You may have to offer more than one counteroffer. Sure, it may seem like a waste of your time especially if you’re still recovering, but the back-and-forth offers are pretty much a standard in personal injury settlement processes.

You Don’t Have to Settle Until You’re Healed

During your recovery process, you don’t have to accept any settlement. You can’t be sure what your costs will be in the end, so you don’t have to take the first (low-ball) offer.

remember that once you accept an offer, you can’t go back and file for a new personal injury lawsuit and ask for more money.

This is why it’s important to think well about the offer. If it’s necessary allow your attorney to negotiate until you get a satisfying settlement and you know will cover all your injury-related expenses.

We have experience with personal injury claims and negotiations. Our mission is to help you get the settlement you deserve. We offer you a free case evaluation; we’ll advise you on the next steps in your case and will help you write a demand letter as well as a counteroffer.

Contact our office today and schedule your first consultation.

Zoom Screenshot_16.png

Content checked by the personal injury attorney Ross Cellino. As a family man and a trial attorney, I pride myself on winning cases and serving the community. With over 35 years of experience, I understand the function of a jury, how juries arrive at conclusions, and the role that the jury plays in administering justice. I know how to win cases. You can find us in Manhattan, Buffalo, Melville, Rochester, Brooklyn, The Bronx, Queens and other locations throughout New York.



Free Case Review




  • I just want to let you know that I did receive my settlement check. More importantly, I want to thank you again for all you did for both me and my family. I could not be more pleased with my experience at Cellino Law. From the moment I first spoke with you I felt comfortable - you took a sincere interest in my case, clearly explained the process and effected a quick settlement. From this day forward, when someone asks if I can recommend a good lawyer I will, without hesitation, say "Cellino Law". Thanks again.


  • I am so grateful for your expertise, patience, and perseverance which resulted with such a successful settlement regarding my car accident. I also want to let you know how impressed I was with you and your firm and I won't hesitate to recommend you to anyone who needs assistance from an accident. I truly appreciated your care and professionalism. Thank you again for your kindness and support


  • This is to express our gratitude to you and your team in helping us and Stephanie navigate through the legal process following her car accident. We are very satisfied with the outcome and grateful for your hard work and attention to details. We fell confident that with this compensation, Stephanie will be able to move forward with her studies and her life with the ability to care for some of her health needs resulting from the injuries sustained following her car accident. Thank you very much and may God continue to bless your efforts.

    Jose & Rose

  • My experience during the time of negotiations was extremely positive. Josh Sandberg handled my lawsuit with the utmost integrity. He returned all my phone calls in a timely manner and answered all my questions. Josh made things less stressful. I would highly recommend Josh and the entire staff at Cellino Law.


  • I can only say great things about my attorney Allan Silverstein. He is professional, he calls back right away, he keeps me informed, and makes me feel comfortable as this entire ordeal is stressful. I have total confidence in his ability to handle whatever comes his way. He is no nonsense and very good at his job. Thank you Allan... he is a true asset to the team!

    Mrs Steward

  • Cellino Law was a great company to work with. From the beginning they came out and met with my uncle and myself and assured us that everything would be taken care of from beginning to end our lawyer state and constant contact with us to make sure that everything would go smoothly and it did. I would definitely recommend anybody to go to Cellino Law for whatever help they need. And specifically please ask for the lawyer that we had Mr. Alan Silverstein. He was amazing and his staff was always attentive. Please go with them for your next law needs.