Skip to content
Determining Liability in Multiple-Vehicle Accidents in New York
Legal Insights | | 6 min

Determining Liability in Multiple-Vehicle Accidents in New York

By Timothy Cellino

Multiple-vehicle accidents can involve extensive injuries for the parties involved, and there is likely to be a dispute over who is liable for damages. In a situation like this, you really need the expertise of an auto accident lawyer to be able to navigate the personal injury claims process. 

Our team at Cellino Law can help determine who is at fault so that you can pursue the compensation you are entitled to from the appropriate party. We understand that you may be overwhelmed with medical bills, lost wages, and other damages, and we are here to help.

The auto accident attorneys of Cellino Law are available to discuss your multi-vehicle pile-up accident claim in greater detail in a free consultation. You can contact our team to schedule a time by calling us at (888) 888-8888 or reach out through our online form today.

Determining Liability in Multiple-Vehicle Accidents in New York

How Do Multiple-Vehicle Accidents Happen on New York Roads

Many multiple-vehicle accidents start out like any other car accident. One driver gets distracted or impatient, fails to yield or merge without looking, makes any number of poor driving decisions, and collides with another motorist. Depending on the location, this can block traffic.

At a certain point before a pile-up, other vehicles are unable to swerve around the original motorists, especially if they are traveling at high speeds. When additional vehicles hit the first motorists, more debris is created, and the vehicles can become an obstacle to the traffic behind them. 

Other factors, like low visibility conditions, poor weather, or road layout, can contribute to the likelihood of a multi-car collision. For example, in foggy conditions or when navigating a curve, a driver may be unable to see the wrecked cars until it is too late for them to stop, adding to the pile-up.

Each new car exacerbates the situation. Unfortunately, the result can be a mass casualty event with injuries ranging from scapes and broken bones to incapacitating head and back injuries. In many cases, motorists become trapped in the wreckage as more vehicles join the melee. 

What Does It Mean to Be Liable in a Personal Injury Lawsuit 

When a party in a personal injury lawsuit is described as “liable,” it means that they have a legal obligation to something. In the context of personal injury law, the liable party is the person or group that is held financially responsible for reimbursing the plaintiff or injured party for their losses.

It should be noted that the party who was negligent is not always the same party who is held liable for the injured party’s damages. In the case of most car accidents resulting from reckless behaviors like speeding, the driver who caused the crash is negligent, but the insurance carrier is liable.

In order to prove liability in a personal injury lawsuit, certain conditions must be satisfied. To begin with, the negligent party must have owed the injured party a duty of care, which is a legal obligation to behave with reasonable caution. It must also be proven that their actions were a breach of that duty.

Provided that those terms can be satisfied, the injured party must still show that the breach caused their injuries, which led to their damages. However, fault has already been established, and if any compensation is going to be provided to the plaintiff, the defendant will be the one to pay.

Most commonly, the defendant is actually the insurance carrier for the negligent driver, as they accept liability for the driver’s actions in exchange for the driver paying for car insurance. In effect, the insurance company serves in the stead of the driver.

What Happens If More Than One Party is At Fault in a New York Crash Involving Multiple Vehicles

When there are multiple vehicles involved in the same collision, ascertaining who caused the crash can quickly become complicated. For some drivers, a collision was unavoidable. For others, their actions caused or contributed to other motorists being injured in the pile-up.

Oftentimes, car accident lawyers will bring in accident reconstructionists to help visualize the pile-up. They create renderings of the accident based on video of the pile-up, eyewitness testimony, photos of the wreckage, police reports, and other sources of evidence.

In some cases, there may be multiple issues at hand. For example, maybe the original driver side-swiped another vehicle because they were texting. However, the driver that ran into those two vehicles was speeding or had issues breaking due to a manufacturing defect with their car.

It is important to sort out negligence not just for the purposes of knowing who should be held primarily for causing the accident but also to know who should receive a reduced settlement for their contribution to their own injuries. New York is a comparative negligence state.

This means that an injured plaintiff can recover compensation for their damages, even if they were partially responsible for the crash. However, whatever percentage of fault they contributed is subtracted from the final settlement. This is seen as a fairer way to handle multiple liable parties.

Choose Cellino Law to Represent You in Your Multiple-Vehicle Accident Claim

Our team at Cellino Law has had over 65 years to carefully hone our skill set to secure the best possible results for our injured clients. We have proudly served New Yorkers who have been unfairly saddled with medical bills, lost income, emotional distress, and other damages.

You can trust our team to be diligent in our pursuit of fair compensation and dedicated to holding the appropriate party accountable for your losses. Clients trust us to put their needs first, and we have proven time and again that we are more than capable of prioritizing client satisfaction.

Contact Cellino Law About Filing a New York Auto Accident Lawsuit Today

At Cellino Law, our detail-oriented approach is a significant asset in cases like multi-vehicle pile-ups where determining liability is often complicated. We are fully prepared to take on complex claims and commit to maximizing your compensation for your damages.

When you hire the personal injury lawyers of Cellino Law, you can expect outstanding results. Reach out to our team by calling us at (888) 888-8888 or contacting us through our online form to schedule a free consultation with a seasoned auto accident attorney.

Content checked by the personal injury attorney Timothy Cellino

Timothy Cellino

As a family man and a trial attorney, I pride myself on winning cases and serving the community.
I understand the function of a jury, how juries arrive at conclusions, and the role that the jury plays in administering justice. I know how to win cases. You can find us in ManhattanBuffaloMelvilleRochesterBrooklynThe BronxQueens and other locations throughout New York.

Share this Article:

New York Personal Injury Lawyers

Client Testimonials

Over 1,000 Google Reviews →
Construction Accident

“thank you so much for putting your all into this and making sure my family and I wouldn’t have to worry anymore!”

— Anthony M.

Personal Injury

“They consistently went above and beyond to make sure my family and I were taken care of.”

— Ira M.

Manhattan, New York
Motorcycle Accident

“The excellent lawyers at Celino Law offices are assisting me with a recent motorcycle accident case.”

— Justin V.

Manhattan, New York
Slip and Fall Accident

“I’m glad I chose Cellino Law, the best decision ever.”

— Joseph C.

Manhattan, New York
Personal Injury

“They were with me and my husband from the beginning to the end of our case.”

— Maria R.

Manhattan, New York
Personal Injury

“From the beginning they came out and met with my uncle and myself and assured us that everything would be taken care of from beginning to end.”

— Eshaunda R.

Manhattan, New York
Car Accident

“I’m very thankful that I took the step to reach out about my case with Cellino Law.”

— Selin S.

Manhattan, New York
Car Accident

“Instead of feeling like “just another case,” I felt valued and respected every step of the way.”

— Gabriella T.

Brooklyn, New York
Car Accident

““Best law firm around‼️”

— Karon O.

Rochester, New York
Mass Tort

“They made me feel comfortable throughout this experience. I was treated with respect and dignity, they kept me well-informed throughout the process, and the outcome was better than I could have expected. I highly recommend Cellino Law!”

— Sandy L.

Rochester, New York
Personal Injury

“they made me feel very comfortable, almost like a family member.”

— Carol W.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“AMAZING ATTORNEYS AND PARALEGALS!”

— Donna B.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“They have been respectful of our circumstances and responsive to our many questions. And they get results.”

— Nick P.

Rochester, New York
Slip and Fall Accident

“I would highly recommend this law office to any individual that has gone through a traumatic experience. Very reliable, effective and efficient.”

— Tatyanna W.

Rochester, New York
Pedestrian Accident

“after being dropped by a Buffalo attorney who stated I would not even see $10,000 from my accident, the Cellino Law team were amazing and able to get me 9.5 times what the previous attorney said I would get.”

— Nichole L.

Rochester, New York
Slip and Fall Accident

“even when I felt doubtful going through a law suit the reassurance was there,I do recommend their services ,if you are looking for professional and concerned firm Cellino Law is it”

— Barbara B.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“I had the unfortunate experience of being involved in a car accident, but I was incredibly fortunate to have Cellino Law Firm represent me in my lawsuit.”

— Guinevere S.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“As someone who had never pursued legal action before, I appreciated how simple they made the process.”

— Brenda P.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“The start of every conversation I was asked how I was doing, how the recovery from my injury/surgery was going. They gave light in a dark time for me.”

— Jessica A.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“The staff made me feel valued and my case mattered.”

— Sharetta M.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“Took me from 6k to 120k. Helped me get a vital surgery with her representation that essentially saved my life.”

— Allan R.

Amherst, New York
Personal Injury

“I was impressed with how professional and patient my lawyer has been on this journey from the beginning to end.”

— Tabitha M.

Amherst, New York
Personal Injury

“I would 100% recommend Cellino Law for anyone needing a lawyer.”

— Megan S.

Amherst, New York
Truck Accident

“There aren’t enough words to express the professionalism, the respect, and genuine compassion that I was given from the very beginning of the first phone call.”

— Patti D.

Amherst, New York
Trip & Fall

“Cellino Law is one of the best law firms”

— Helen P.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“My case just resolved for a significant amount and I am extremely satisfied. If you are ever injured in a car accident don’t hesitate to call Cellino Law.”

— Monique B.

Amherst, New York
Trip and Fall

“They were professional and knowledgeable and helped my son receive the compensation he deserved.”

— K.R

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“I was in a car accident in February and didn’t know what to do next. That’s when I decided to contact Cellino Law and get some guidance. It was the best decision I could have made!”

— Katie B.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“Best Law Firm period!”

— Pedro A.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“Great team and very attentive. Highly recommend to anyone recently in a car accident.”

— Randi B.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“They are very knowledgeable and take dedicated time to make sure you get what you deserve and will keep working to your best interest.”

— Katrina M.

Buffalo, New York
Personal Injury

“If you need a compassionate and skilled attorney, I highly recommend Cellino Law. They truly care about their clients.”

— J R.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“Their professionalism made a stressful situation much easier. Highly recommend!”

— Eric B.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“They were incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and always made me feel supported and informed throughout the entire process.”

— Anne S.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“They treat you like more than just a case, and make you comfortable throughout the whole process.”

— Ann W.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“My attorney came to my home because at that point I was unable to walk…”

— Crisanne

Rear-End Accident

“…the attorney that they gave me was a godsend.”

— Merri

Slip and Fall Accident

“Recently I had a slip and fall at a restaurant and injured my knee. It led to me missing work and having to go to multiple doctors appts, MRIs and now PT. A friend of mine suggested I contact an attorney given the severity of the injury. I reached out to Cellino Law and spoke with Brigitte Cellino and her paralegal Katie C. They have been so helpful and informative throughout this whole process, and have been checking in on me frequently to see how I’m doing. Class acts at Cellino, the best around! Call them if you’re looking for a lawyer!”

— Paul K.

Buffalo, New York
Personal Injury

“I was hoping my attorney would help me figure out how I was going to help take care of my family…”

— Anthony

Car Accident

“I was in a car accident in February and didn’t know what to do next. That’s when I decided to contact Cellino Law and get some guidance. It was the best decision I could have made!”

— Katie B.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“Getting into a car accident is scary and stressful, figuring out what to do next is even more overwhelming. The staff at Cellino law firm are so kind, understanding and helpful. They treat you like more than just a case, and make you comfortable throughout the whole process. Brigitte Cellino and her assistant Katie C, are the best, and go above and beyond for their clients!”

— Ann W.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“My attorney was able to find the woman that hit me and because of that we were able to have a case…”

— Paulette

Camper Trailer

“We had purchased a camper, and they didn’t put the lug nuts on the wheels…”

— Cristiane

Personal Injury

“I am incredibly grateful for the exceptional service provided by Cellino Law, specifically attorney Joseph DeGeneres and his outstanding assistant, Ian. From the very beginning, Joseph demonstrated a remarkable level of professionalism and expertise. He took the time to explain every detail of my case, answered all my questions, and provided honest, realistic expectations. Ian was always available to assist, ensuring that communication was seamless and that I was kept informed throughout the process. Their dedication and commitment to my case resulted in a favorable outcome, and I couldn’t be happier with the results. I highly recommend Cellino Law to anyone in need of legal representation.”

— Chris C.

Rochester, New York
Burn

“After Cellino Law helped me reach a settlement, my life has been a complete one hundred eighty.”

— Melissa

Rear-End Accident

Nick Davis, my lawyer from Cellino Law, listens! Shortly after I was severely rear ended in a car accident I realized I’d need a lawyer and sent emails to a few top companies. Nick Davis was the first to respond (others took days or didn’t respond) and he listened. He worked hard for me and always kept me informed. He and his paralegal Laurie Pecora were always available to answer my questions and explain the process. I am very happy with the outcome and highly recommend Cellino Law.”

— Sherry R.

Rochester, New York
Compound Fracture

“They were professional and knowledgeable and helped my son receive the compensation he deserved.”

— K.R.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“I can’t thank Cellino Law enough for everything they have done for me. When Denis Bastible took my case for a rear end car accident over 3 years ago I had no idea what this would turn into. I had to have 3 years of treatment on my back and eventually leading to a back surgery, which at 25 years old is a nightmare. Denis and his paralegal Marisa were nothing but a huge help to me the entire way through the lawsuit process. They were very reassuring that this would end well for me and extremely easy to contact throughout the entire process. If I could give them more than 5 stars I would.”

— Tyler M.

Amherst, New York
Truck Accident

“I said to them ‘if you were going to use a law firm who would you use?’ and time after time the name Cellino came up.”

— Andre

Truck Accident

author image
Truck Accident

Truck Accident

Yes, You Have A Case.

Fill out the form below and we will respond to you shortly.