Can You File A Diminished Value Claim Against Your Own Insurance In Manhattan?

Can You File A Diminished Value Claim Against Your Own Insurance In Manhattan?
Calendar icon March 13, 2024
File a diminished value claim against your own insurance in Manhattan

New York motorists may submit claims to their insurance carriers to recover vehicle damage losses. They may also need to show that they’re not responsible for causing the accidents that damaged their cars.

After an accident, a car’s resale value decreases even if fully and expertly repaired. You may, however, have grounds for a diminished value claim. An experienced attorney can determine how to proceed if an insurance company attempts to deny your request.

How Soon After an Accident Can I Submit a Diminished Value Claim?

Under the Empire State’s statute of limitations, you have three years after a vehicle accident to file any claims. Have you already submitted a property damage claim with the other motorist’s insurance policy to recover your losses? If not, you may wish to consider having a knowledgeable attorney review your options before proceeding.

After a auto collision, most owners have their damaged or wrecked cars repaired by a mechanic or auto body shop before submitting their claims to the at-fault motorist’s insurance policy. The at-fault party’s liability coverage will usually cover the basic repair costs. The resale or market value of a vehicle repaired after a collision could, however, decrease by thousands of dollars.

Reasons to submit a diminished value claim

Property damage claims may include compensation for the loss of a vehicle’s value that resulted from an accident in spite of its subsequent repairs. A diminished value claim could prove especially beneficial for those enthusiastic owners who upgraded their cars or installed customized features and hoped to see an increase in their car’s resale value. The damage caused by an accident may, however, negate the value of custom installations or leave a car worthless.

Did a collision reduce the worth of your car? If you believe that a third party appraisal of your vehicle’s diminished value falls below its fair market resale value, you may consider seeking another opinion. An experienced attorney can calculate your car’s worth before and after the collision so you could get the compensation you really deserve.

What Methods Could Determine the Diminished Value of My Car?

Diminished value determinations typically fall into one of three categories. An attorney will know which valuation method could recover the optimal compensation from an insurance company.

Claims based on the immediate diminished value

If you file a claim based on an “immediate diminished value,” its calculation considers the worth of a car immediately after its collision. This valuation method assumes that, because of the crash, the vehicle has lost this degree of value before taking it in for repairs. With this formula, an insurance company may attempt to pay you only for the cost of repairs.

Claim submissions based on an inherent diminished value

After taking a wrecked car in for repairs, its resale value remains decreased even if a skilled mechanic or auto body shop restores it back to its original “pre-accident” condition. The vehicle now has a lower market value because of its collision history, even if the repairs used original parts from the manufacturer and made it look and run “like new.”

If you advertise your car for sale in this condition, potential buyers may not agree to pay you its full resale value because of the crash. An “inherent diminished value” claim could cover the monetary differential for what the vehicle would have sold for if no collision occurred.

Claims based on a repair-related diminished value

In some cases, the repair work may incorporate “third-party” replacement components rather than the vehicle manufacturer’s recommended “original equipment” parts. The repair shop may also repaint a newly repaired vehicle with substandard paint products that take away from a car’s value. In a repair-related diminished value claim, an insurance company could pay for the lost value attributable to any less-than-top-notch repair shop work.

How Can an Attorney Help Me With a Diminished Value Claim?

The aftermath of a car accident often becomes stressful when vehicle owners or their loved ones also require medical treatment or an extended recovery. One of the many ways an experienced accident attorney can help you get through a difficult time is by relieving you of the need to get involved in post-accident negotiations with an insurance company. You can instead remain focused on healing and moving forward from the crash event while remaining assured that a skilled and trusted attorney handles your case.

An experienced claims attorney also knows the formulas that insurance companies use to calculate a compensation package. Most auto insurers use the 17c Diminished Value Formula to calculate a damage award for a wrecked vehicle.

How the 17c Diminished Value Formula works

Knowing the current and undamaged market resale value of your car could help you get an idea of what an insurance adjuster may offer in a diminished value claim. The Kelly Blue Book provides the current resale value of your car based on its year, model, make and mileage. Keep in mind that the KBB “book value” of your car assumes it’s in an undamaged condition and has no history of accidents. The National Automotive Dealers Association also provides similar resale value information.

Because of the damage done to a vehicle during a collision, insurance company adjusters will typically subtract a “base loss of value” amount from the current market resale value provided by the KBB or NADA. The amount that’s left after subtracting that amount, which may reflect as much as a 90% reduction of the KBB or NADA current value, is a first step in determining what an insurance company might offer in response to a diminished value claim. The next step that an adjuster would use in the 17c Diminished Value Formula involves applying multipliers ranging from 0.00 to 1.00 to determine a value that coincides with the severity of the car’s structural damage.

How Could an Attorney Increase the Payout?

Insurance companies may not consider the true resale value of cars involved in damage claims. How well, for example, does the KBB or NADA value of your vehicle reflect what it may sell for in Manhattan?

A knowledgeable car accident attorney can determine your optimal settlement amount in a diminished value claim. An attorney familiar with insurance companies’ negotiation tactics can present convincing data that could significantly increase the amount of an insurance company’s payout.

Zoom Screenshot_16.png

Content checked by the personal injury attorney Ross Cellino. As a family man and a trial attorney, I pride myself on winning cases and serving the community. With over 35 years of experience, I understand the function of a jury, how juries arrive at conclusions, and the role that the jury plays in administering justice. I know how to win cases. You can find us in Manhattan, Buffalo, Melville, Rochester, Brooklyn, The Bronx, Queens and other locations throughout New York.



Free Case Review




  • I really just wanted to say thank you so much for taking my case, answering all my questions, and mostly for being very patient with me. I feel that without you and Roza I would not have been able to get anything at all. I hope to never need a lawyer again, but if I do I will definitely want you both working for me. Again thank your for you hard work, time and patience.


  • I can only say great things about my attorney Allan Silverstein. He is professional, he calls back right away, he keeps me informed, and makes me feel comfortable as this entire ordeal is stressful. I have total confidence in his ability to handle whatever comes his way. He is no nonsense and very good at his job. Thank you Allan... he is a true asset to the team!

    Mrs Steward

  • Cellino Law and more specifically my attorney, Gregory V. Pajak, Managing Attorney, and as a whole the Cellino Law Firm and its organization. This is by far one of the most professional law firms and attorney I have ever engaged with and retained in my 35 years. The level of professionalism goes beyond words, the care and constant engagement with me as the client was touching. I was never ever just treated as simply a CASE with potentially a significant dollar number attached to my file. I was engaged regularly, Tracey (Ass’t) and Greg always made sure to remain constant, as well as consistent in overseeing that my case was handled properly and that it did matter in many ways - ensuring that the end result(s) would be fair and reasonable to my case/injury. The regular follow-up calls were very satisfying, knowing that you’re involved in your case matters significantly AND always. One of my main items to recognize Cellino Law and Gregory is that whenever I called, I was able to get through to speak directly to my Lawyer and he would answer any if not all of my questions in a very professional and genuinely caring manner. I always felt cared for and protected legally and more importantly, I was made feel as a human being that was being cared for and always keeping me abreast of all matters connected to the case. There was never a point I felt let down, on the contrary -the level of service was “STELLAR”. Greg is the consummate professional, a ‘role model’, if you will, for what other attorneys should strive to become when dealing with their clients.


  • Choosing the right attorney to represent you after an accident can make all the difference. This is no cliche. I recently experienced these words to live by first hand. After a tractor trailer rear ended me at high speed in 2017 I retained Allan Silverstein to handle my case. I quickly realized that bringing a lawsuit rapidly snowballs into a mountain of details that can make or break your results. Documents, case histories, doctor visits, bills, and lots of phone calls all need to be accurately kept track of if a successful outcome it to be attained. To complicate matters I reside in New York and the incident took place in New Jersey. Luckily, Allan was licensed in multiple states. I was fortunate to find Allan to handle this matter from the New York area. Armed with an accurate account of the facts Allan went to work on the difficult job of negotiating with the defending insurance company as well as my no fault carrier in order to obtain the best possible outcome for my set of circumstances. In a lawsuit communication is key and and events can be of a timely nature. Allan never failed to return my calls - usually the same day! He fought skillfully and respectfully to get me the best possible settlement. He is easy to deal with and a likeable down to earth guy. He always listened with compassion and respect to my issues. He guided me with objective understanding as well as a realistic analysis of the merits of my case. When we finally settled Allan got me a fair agreement beyond my expectations and negotiated with my doctors to make sure all my bills were paid. It was a great experience having Allan represent me. Quality work in any aspect of life is hard to find. Quality is what I got with Allan Silverstein. I highly recommend him if you find yourself in need of a personal injury attorney.


  • My wife and I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for a fantastic job as our attorney. We could not have been more pleased with the work you and your team has done on this case. This past four years or so has been such a roller coaster for our family. We are very pleased and grateful with the result. We have made a good choice by choosing you. Thank you.


  • Mark Kochanowicz is from far the best attorney you can have. Mark treats you like a friend more than a client. He truly cares and go the extra mile for you and your case, contacts you to update you in regards to your case and keep you informed at all times. Mark represented me twice and settled my cases for way more than I expected. I highly recommend Mark Kochanowicz because he is just the best on what he does!!! Thank you Mark!!!!