What To Do If Insurance Is Not Paying Enough For A Totaled Car

When your vehicle is damaged in an accident, your insurance company will work with repair facilities to fix it. However, insurers will declare the car a total loss when the cost of repairs exceeds 75% of its current market value. If you have a new SUV, you may end up with a car that has been nearly rebuilt because of its high value. On the other hand, if you rely on an older car to commute to work, you may find yourself with a proposed payout that is insufficient as a down payment on a replacement.

You may be curious about how likely you are to find yourself in this situation. According to the Institute for Traffic Safety Management and Research, over 392,000 motor vehicle accidents were reported on New York roadways in 2021. Of those, more than 71% resulted in property damage. So, there’s a reasonable chance you will experience an accident that causes property damage at some point.

Being involved in a car accident is stressful enough without worrying about how much your insurance company will pay for damages. However, in the case of a serious accident where your car is considered a total loss, the amount you are offered may be significantly lower than expected.

Like many other drivers, you may wonder what to do when the figure you receive from the insurance company is not enough to replace your vehicle with a similar one. We’ll work to explain what steps you can take if you find yourself in that situation.

Order an Appraisal

The first step you should take in this situation is to order an appraisal. Some insurance policies have an appraisal clause that can resolve discrepancies between the initial offer and your car’s pre-accident value.

An appraised value is primarily based on the year, make and model of your vehicle, but it can be affected by other circumstances. For example, custom modifications can increase a car’s value. Additionally, antique and classic cars often have a cash value significantly higher than their original sticker price.

Be prepared to provide maintenance records that establish the vehicle’s history and a recent odometer reading. This can help show the vehicle’s pre-accident condition. In addition, if you have the original window sticker, check it to ensure all options are included in your appraisal.

Try To Negotiate With the Insurance Company

Armed with a written appraisal, you can begin negotiations with the insurance company. You have the most critical information needed to get a higher settlement or to remove your car from being considered a total loss: The current cash value of your vehicle as it was immediately before the crash.

You may still be able to negotiate without an appraisal. Start by going through the insurance adjuster’s written estimate. Point out any inaccuracies and provide the insurance company with copies of supporting documentation, such as maintenance records or the window sticker. If they don’t budge on the appraisal, you may need to try a different approach.

Appeal to Emotions

You may be surprised to discover that insurance companies aren’t all about numbers. Appealing to the emotional aspect of the crash and how the loss of your vehicle impacts daily life can help in some situations. You might also find success by providing photos of the accident, emphasizing its seriousness.

Prepare a Counteroffer

Instead of waiting for the adjuster to make a move, present a written counteroffer to his appraisal. Be realistic; you do not want to pull a figure out of thin air. Instead, use online tools to estimate the value of the car’s resale (not trade-in) value. Remember to account for any extra features or modifications to the vehicle that affect its value.

The sooner you start on a counteroffer, the more prepared you will be. That often means starting research immediately after an accident if you anticipate a total loss determination.

Present a Written Estimate for Repairs

New York uses a formula that allows for repairs above estimated costs. However, if the insurance estimates for repairs seem unusually low, getting a written estimate from a body shop may help better demonstrate the value of your car.

Get Your Settlement in Writing

It is good practice to document all communication between you and the insurance company or other entities involved in determining your car’s value. This is especially important for any settlement offers presented to you. Keeping communication in writing makes this easier. Use email or certified mail whenever possible to ensure you have proof of conversations and proposals.

Take the Case to Arbitration

New York auto insurance rules allow for arbitration in certain situations. Arbitration puts a fresh, unbiased set of eyes on the issue at hand: your car’s cash value. During this process, you will meet with an insurance company representative and a licensed arbitrator to attempt to find a mutually agreeable settlement. While it is not required, you may have an attorney present during this process.

File a Lawsuit

Negotiating with the insurance company should be your first step in trying to get a larger insurance settlement. However, it may not be successful, and you should be prepared for that outcome. You may need to take your case to court if you cannot negotiate a settlement.

Unless you are well-versed in litigation, this is an area for professionals. For that reason, hiring an attorney is advisable at this step, even if you handled negotiations independently.

When you use our law firm, you only pay if we win in court or obtain a favorable settlement. That means there are no upfront costs to worry about. Scheduling a free, no-obligation case evaluation is an excellent way to determine if filing a lawsuit is a viable option for you.

Buy Back Your Totaled Car

You may be able to buy your totaled car back from the insurance company. In a typical arrangement, you will keep the vehicle with a salvage title and complete any repairs yourself. This is a viable option for some car owners. For example, if you have an older car with a low cash value, even minimal repairs can cause it to be declared a total loss. You would not be able to replace that car with the insurance payout, so fixing it might be worthwhile.

There are some downsides to this arrangement. For example, the insurance payout is lowered by the estimated cost of repairs. Additionally, there may be limitations on what types of insurance you can purchase for the car after repairs are complete.

Secure Legal Counsel

You have several options to secure a more favorable settlement if your insurance company is not offering a high enough payout for your totaled vehicle. However, many of those can be challenging to navigate on your own. Therefore, speaking with an accident attorney early in the process is a good idea. He will help you evaluate your options and respond appropriately to the insurance company.

If you are involved in an auto accident, Cellino Law can help. Our firm has a long history of helping New York accident victims, stretching over 60 years. We offer a free, no-obligation case review to uncover your legal options. Contact us to find your local office and get the help you need to get a fair payout from your insurance company.



Free Case Review



  • I can only say great things about my attorney Allan Silverstein. He is professional, he calls back right away, he keeps me informed, and makes me feel comfortable as this entire ordeal is stressful. I have total confidence in his ability to handle whatever comes his way. He is no nonsense and very good at his job. Thank you Allan... he is a true asset to the team!

    Mrs Steward

  • Mark Kochanowicz is from far the best attorney you can have. Mark treats you like a friend more than a client. He truly cares and go the extra mile for you and your case, contacts you to update you in regards to your case and keep you informed at all times. Mark represented me twice and settled my cases for way more than I expected. I highly recommend Mark Kochanowicz because he is just the best on what he does!!! Thank you Mark!!!!


  • I am writing to let you know what an outstanding job George Gridelli did for me in my personal injury lawsuit. His professionalism and expertise were evident at our first metting and he and his paralegal Diane D'Andrea took care of me as if I was a friend and not merely a client. They both went above and beyond for me in so many ways that it would be too numerous to list and I am grateful to have had such an exemplary team represent me. When working with George and watching him in court he personified to me what a lawyer is supposed to be - an honest, extremely compentent man who helped guide me through the legal system. I could not have obtained better representation anywhere else at any price. To me that says a lot abut you and your firm's integrity. Thank you again for representing me and for having such stellar individuals working for you! I will continue to recommend your firm.


  • I highly recommend Cellino Law to anyone involved in a car crash. I worked with Michael Lovecchio, and had a wonderful experience given the circumstances. He was very attentive, and got the best possible outcome I could have wanted.


  • Choosing the right attorney to represent you after an accident can make all the difference. This is no cliche. I recently experienced these words to live by first hand. After a tractor trailer rear ended me at high speed in 2017 I retained Allan Silverstein to handle my case. I quickly realized that bringing a lawsuit rapidly snowballs into a mountain of details that can make or break your results. Documents, case histories, doctor visits, bills, and lots of phone calls all need to be accurately kept track of if a successful outcome it to be attained. To complicate matters I reside in New York and the incident took place in New Jersey. Luckily, Allan was licensed in multiple states. I was fortunate to find Allan to handle this matter from the New York area. Armed with an accurate account of the facts Allan went to work on the difficult job of negotiating with the defending insurance company as well as my no fault carrier in order to obtain the best possible outcome for my set of circumstances. In a lawsuit communication is key and and events can be of a timely nature. Allan never failed to return my calls - usually the same day! He fought skillfully and respectfully to get me the best possible settlement. He is easy to deal with and a likeable down to earth guy. He always listened with compassion and respect to my issues. He guided me with objective understanding as well as a realistic analysis of the merits of my case. When we finally settled Allan got me a fair agreement beyond my expectations and negotiated with my doctors to make sure all my bills were paid. It was a great experience having Allan represent me. Quality work in any aspect of life is hard to find. Quality is what I got with Allan Silverstein. I highly recommend him if you find yourself in need of a personal injury attorney.


  • I really just wanted to say thank you so much for taking my case, answering all my questions, and mostly for being very patient with me. I feel that without you and Roza I would not have been able to get anything at all. I hope to never need a lawyer again, but if I do I will definitely want you both working for me. Again thank your for you hard work, time and patience.